ZMIME
Research & knowledge work

Academic peer reviews AI prompts.

Evaluate the supplied manuscript against its field’s stated criteria.

Replace the bracketed fields with your information before using a prompt.

Start the task

Act as a research analyst.

Task — Evaluate the supplied manuscript against its field’s stated criteria.

Context — [describe the situation and intended audience].
Required information — Research question, supplied sources, discipline, scope, method and citation requirements.
Source material — [paste the relevant facts, text, data or documentation].
Constraints — [length, format, dates, budget, terminology and requirements].
Deliver — Major concerns, minor concerns and actionable evidence-linked feedback.

Use the supplied facts. Identify missing information before relying on it. Preserve names, figures, units and qualifications. Mark assumptions and use placeholders for facts that need confirmation. Ask focused questions if a missing fact would materially change the result.

Improve a draft

Review the following draft as a research analyst.

Original task — Evaluate the supplied manuscript against its field’s stated criteria.
Required deliverable — Major concerns, minor concerns and actionable evidence-linked feedback.
Audience and constraints — [paste the requirements].
Source material — [paste the facts or references].
Draft — [paste the draft].
Requested changes — [describe the improvement].

Check factual support, completeness, clarity and format. Return the revised draft and a short list of material changes. Mark unresolved questions and retain verified facts.

Check the result

Evaluate this result against the supplied requirements.

Task — Evaluate the supplied manuscript against its field’s stated criteria.
Expected deliverable — Major concerns, minor concerns and actionable evidence-linked feedback.
Requirements and evidence — [paste the brief and sources].
Result — [paste the output].

Return a table of requirement, evidence in the result, any issue and suggested correction. Check calculations, citations, consistency and missing inputs where relevant. Finish with the specific items a human should verify before using the result.