Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct vs Magistral Small 1.2 vs Gemma 3 27B IT
Too close to call on our weighted score (Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 51, Gemma 3 27B IT 50, Magistral Small 1.2 45). The right pick depends on what you value most.
Price in rating: Included · Exclude price
Meta
Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct
51/100- ECI127.8
- Price$0.17 / $0.59
- Context10M
Mistral AI
Magistral Small 1.2
45/100- ECI—
- Price$0.50 / $1.50
- Context131K
Google
Gemma 3 27B IT
50/100- ECI127.5
- Price$0.10 / $0.299
- Context131K
Too close to call
It is close. Our weighted score puts them within 1 points (Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 51/100, Gemma 3 27B IT 50/100, Magistral Small 1.2 45/100), so choose by what matters most for your work: Magistral Small 1.2 for raw capability, Gemma 3 27B IT on price and Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct for long inputs. The score weighs capability 50%, price 25%, inputs & features 15%, context window 10%. Capability uses the average of shared benchmarks (GPQA Diamond and OTIS Mock AIME 2024–2025), because Magistral Small 1.2 has no Capabilities Index score yet.
- CapabilityMagistral Small 1.2Shared benchmarks: Magistral Small 1.2 37.8% · Gemma 3 27B IT 35.1% · Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 29.8%
- Lowest priceGemma 3 27B ITGemma 3 27B IT $0.15 · Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct $0.275 · Magistral Small 1.2 $0.75 per 1M tokens (3:1 blend)
- Longest contextLlama 4 Scout 17B InstructLlama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 10,000,000 · Magistral Small 1.2 131,072 · Gemma 3 27B IT 131,072 tokens
- Widest inputsSame inputsLlama 4 Scout 17B Instruct: Text, Images · Magistral Small 1.2: Text, Images · Gemma 3 27B IT: Text, Images
- Self-hostingAll open weightsEvery model here can be downloaded and run on your own hardware
| Measure | Weight | Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct | Magistral Small 1.2 | Gemma 3 27B IT |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| CapabilityShared benchmarks | 50% | 30 | 38 | 35 |
| Price | 25% | 73 | 53 | 85 |
| Inputs & features | 15% | 50 | 60 | 50 |
| Context window | 10% | 100 | 32 | 32 |
| Overall | 100% | 51/100 | 45/100 | 50/100 |
Every spec in one table
Highlighted cells lead their row. Dashes mean the data is not published.
| Specification | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Capability | |||
| Capabilities Index (ECI) | 127.8 (best) | — | 127.5 |
| ECI rank | #140 of 158 (best) | — | #141 of 158 |
| GPQA DiamondGraduate-level science questions | 51.8% (best) | 47.6% | 47.7% |
| OTIS Mock AIME 2024–2025Competition mathematics | 7.8% | 28.1% (best) | 22.5% |
| Price per million tokens | |||
| Input | $0.17 | $0.50 | $0.10 (best) |
| Output | $0.59 | $1.50 | $0.299 (best) |
| Cached input | — | — | — |
| Blended (3:1) | $0.275 | $0.75 | $0.15 (best) |
| Long-context rate | Same rate | Same rate | Same rate |
| Price source | Median of 13 providers | Median of 1 providers | Median of 17 providers |
| Limits | |||
| Context window | 10,000,000 tokens (best) | 131,072 tokens | 131,072 tokens |
| Max output | 16,384 tokens | 131,072 tokens (best) | 131,072 tokens (best) |
| Inputs and features | |||
| Text | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Images | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| PDFs | No | No | No |
| Audio | No | No | No |
| Video | No | No | No |
| Reasoning | No | Yes | No |
| Tool calling | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Structured output | No | No | No |
| Availability | |||
| Weights | Open | OpenApache 2.0 | Open |
| API model ID | — | — | — |
| API providers | 13 | 1 | 18 (best) |
| Released | Apr 5, 2025 | Sep 18, 2025 | Mar 12, 2025 |
| Knowledge cutoff | Aug 2024 | — | Aug 2024 |
What would a month cost?
Enter your expected volume in millions of tokens. List prices only; caching and batch discounts would lower these.
Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct$2.88
Magistral Small 1.2$8.00
Gemma 3 27B IT$1.60
Which should you choose?
Which is better: Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct, Magistral Small 1.2 or Gemma 3 27B IT?
It is close. Our weighted score puts them within 1 points (Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 51/100, Gemma 3 27B IT 50/100, Magistral Small 1.2 45/100), so choose by what matters most for your work: Magistral Small 1.2 for raw capability, Gemma 3 27B IT on price and Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct for long inputs. The score weighs capability 50%, price 25%, inputs & features 15%, context window 10%. Capability uses the average of shared benchmarks (GPQA Diamond and OTIS Mock AIME 2024–2025), because Magistral Small 1.2 has no Capabilities Index score yet.
Which is cheaper, Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct, Magistral Small 1.2 or Gemma 3 27B IT?
Gemma 3 27B IT is cheaper at $0.10 input / $0.299 output per million tokens (median across 17 API providers). Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct costs $0.17 input / $0.59 output per million tokens (median across 13 API providers); Magistral Small 1.2 costs $0.50 input / $1.50 output per million tokens (median across 1 API provider). At a typical mix of three input tokens to one output token, that is $0.15 per million tokens for Gemma 3 27B IT versus $0.275 for Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct (1.8× as much) and $0.75 for Magistral Small 1.2 (5× as much).
Which scores higher on benchmarks?
Not every model here has a Capabilities Index score, so we compare the average of shared benchmarks (GPQA Diamond and OTIS Mock AIME 2024–2025): Magistral Small 1.2 37.8%, Gemma 3 27B IT 35.1% and Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 29.8%. On individual benchmarks: GPQA Diamond — Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 51.8%, Gemma 3 27B IT 47.7%, Magistral Small 1.2 47.6%; OTIS Mock AIME 2024–2025 — Magistral Small 1.2 28.1%, Gemma 3 27B IT 22.5%, Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct 7.8%.
Which is better for coding?
There are no published SWE-bench Verified results for Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct, Magistral Small 1.2 and Gemma 3 27B IT yet, so there is no like-for-like coding score. On overall capability, Magistral Small 1.2 leads, which tends to carry over to coding, but test on your own codebase. All three support tool calling for agent workflows.
Which has the bigger context window?
Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct has the largest context window at 10,000,000 tokens, against 131,072 for Magistral Small 1.2 and 131,072 for Gemma 3 27B IT. Maximum output per response: Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct up to 16,384, Magistral Small 1.2 up to 131,072, Gemma 3 27B IT up to 131,072 tokens.
Which can read images, PDFs, audio or video?
Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct accepts text and images; Magistral Small 1.2 accepts text and images; Gemma 3 27B IT accepts text and images. They handle the same number of input types.
Are any of these open source?
Yes, all three publish their weights (Apache 2.0), so you can self-host them.
Which is newer?
Magistral Small 1.2 is the newest, released Sep 18, 2025. Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct came out Apr 5, 2025; Gemma 3 27B IT came out Mar 12, 2025. Knowledge cutoff: Llama 4 Scout 17B Instruct Aug 2024, Gemma 3 27B IT Aug 2024.
How do you decide the winner?
This rating uses capability (50%, independent benchmark results); price (25%, blended price per million tokens (3 input : 1 output), log scale); inputs & features (15%, image, PDF, audio and video input, tool calling, structured output and reasoning); context window (10%, maximum tokens per request, log scale). Dimensions missing for any model are dropped and the remaining weights rescaled, so every model is judged on the same evidence. Specs and prices come from public model listings and the labs’ own API pages; capability scores come from independent benchmark runs. Data updated Nov 18, 2026.